American Idol Results

After a couple days of for the most part, great vocals I look forward to seeing who goes home tonight. I always love to see how they act in their group number, and well I think the producers made a fair, but not the best song choice for the top 24. The song ‘American Boy’, really, should the ladies be upset about the lack of political correctness?

Well at least they let the ladies go first:

• Siobhan is safe
• Haeley is safe
• Michelle is safe
• Katelyn is safe ( One of the best I felt from the other night)
• Katie is safe
• Janelle is going home
  • I honestly can say that before she sings her final song I just don’t remember her.  I guess it’s like they say they have to make that great impression.  Now that she’s singing I remember her very well and while I feel she did a good job at the Heart: What about love? It is one of those songs we’ve all heard so many times that it’s very difficult for someone trying to make that great first impression with it on the first night.

Allison comes back and I can’t see I’ve seen much growth since last season She must have taken a year off although I will admit her pitch is better than it was last year.

What’s with the dress it looks like they played pin the tail with the dress and thus some weird thing is glued to her butt. 

Last Row of ladies:

• Paige is safe
• Lacey is safe
  • ( I can’t say I enjoyed her performance this week she needs to step it up. )
• Lilly is safe, Crystal is safe ( I feel she could be a dark horse in this competition if she stops singing as if she is on the streets.  I love her show but need to see more from her. ) Ashley is going home Didi is safe. 
  Ashley we know your upset and you have the right to be but hold on to your composure girl, let the attitude just fall away.  I’m hearing the song for the second time and still don’t remember the first.  Pitch seems to be all over the board, she needs to take a breath and compose herself. 

In my opinion the final performances of these kids need to be as good if not better than what they did during the week  as I feel it’s another chance to kick start your fan base with a composed performance that will leave them looking for your first album.  Sadly I did not get that feeling from this performance.

LOL way to go Tyler showing up to final rehersal in robe, boots and socks. lol

• Okay guys:
  Big Mike – Safe, I like this guy but must admit unless he steps it up he won’t be here long
• John Park Safe
• Aaron – Safe, Now this kid can sing, I like him
• Todrick safe another one I felt had a memorable performance
• Tim is safe and Joe is  not, I can’t believe it.. If you look at the performances Joe was 100 times stronger.  Other than looking like a young Shaun Cassidy, Tim did not offer much in the way of vocal talent at least from what he showed last night.

Kris Allen is singing for Haiti.  A very noble cause.  I hope our contestants are taking good notes for this is what it’s all about at least to me.  When you can feel or be moved by a song or performance that is what makes mountains.  Let it be has there ever been a better written song, I love his unique flavor that he has added.  Maybe I’m too sentimental for my age but he made my heart feel for Haiti.  Great Job.

• Casey James – Safe
  • I feel he will be here till the end, excellent vocal and enjoyable personality.
• Jermaine safe
  • Another contender amongst the men. 
• Lee is safe
• Andrew is safe
• Alex is safe
• Tyler is going home
  • I agreed with Simon completely last night and with all the judges he was there on appearance more than vocal.  It bit him, I do hope he preservers and continues his journey as he can be great he just needs to remember what is important.

Well these are my humble thoughts for tonights Idol Results  Feel free to pipe in with your thoughts.